Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting

Imagine Casting will be shutdown permanently on October 31, 2022.

The site is now in read-only mode. No new casts, polls, votes, or comments can be added.

clear  
clear  

The Dark Knight Returns by Frank Miller

It is ten years after an aging Batman has retired and Gotham City has sunk deeper into decadence and lawlessness. Now as his city needs him most, the Dark Knight returns in a blaze of glory. Joined by Carrie Kelly, a teenage female Robin, Batman takes to the streets to end the threat of the mutant gangs that have overrun the city. And after facing off against his two greatest enemies, the Joker and Two-Face for the final time, Batman finds himself in mortal combat with his former ally, Superman, in a battle that only one of them will survive.

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 33

  1. 1. Zack Snyder 33% 
  2. 2. Christopher Nolan 18% 
  3. 3. David Fincher 12% 
  4. 4. Tim Burton 12% 
  5. 5. John Sayles 6% 
  6. 6. Clint Eastwood 3% 
  7. 7. Mike Newell 3% 
  8. 8. Frank Miller 3% 
  9. 9. Alfonso Cuaron 3% 
  10. 10. James Mangold 3% 
  11. 11. Robert Rodgriguez 3% 

Cast Results

Batman/Bruce Wayne Total Votes: 41

  1. 1. Michael Keaton 29% 
  2. 2. Clint Eastwood 12% 
  3. 3. Bruce Willis 9% 
  4. 4. Christian Bale 7% 
  5. 5. Kurt Russell 7% 
  6. 6. Harrison Ford 4% 
  7. 7. Ed Harris 2% 
  8. 8. Michael Douglas 2% 
  9. 9. Mel Gibson 2% 
  10. 10. Jeffrey Dean Morgan 2% 
  11. 11. Johnny Depp 2% 
  12. 12. David Morse 2% 
  13. 13. Jonathan Banks 2% 
  14. 14. James Caviezel 2% 
  15. 15. Brad Pitt 2% 
  16. 16. Ben Affleck 2% 
  17. 17. Michael Ironside 2% 
  18. 18. Ron Perlman 2% 

Superman/Clark Kent Total Votes: 34

  1. 1. Harrison Ford 23% 
  2. 2. Brandon Routh 17% 
  3. 3. Jon Hamm 14% 
  4. 4. Nicolas Cage 11% 
  5. 5. Henry Cavill 8% 
  6. 6. Josh Brolin 5% 
  7. 7. Dean Cain 2% 
  8. 8. Brad Pitt 2% 
  9. 9. Bruce Willis 2% 
  10. 10. Kurt Russell 2% 
  11. 11. Christian Bale 2% 
  12. 12. Jim Cavizel 2% 

The Joker Total Votes: 39

  1. 1. Jack Nicholson 30% 
  2. 2. Mark Hamill 10% 
  3. 3. Robert Englund 7% 
  4. 4. Gary Oldman 7% 
  5. 5. Crispin Glover 5% 
  6. 6. Jim Carrey 5% 
  7. 7. Geoffrey Rush 2% 
  8. 8. Brad Dourif 2% 
  9. 9. Heath Ledger 2% 
  10. 10. Robin Williams 2% 
  11. 11. Michael Massee 2% 
  12. 12. Michael Emerson 2% 
  13. 13. Jared Leto 2% 
  14. 14. Willem Dafoe 2% 
  15. 15. Daniel Day-Lewis 2% 
  16. 16. James Woods 2% 
  17. 17. Sean Penn 2% 
  18. 18. Nicolas Cage 2% 
  19. 19. Doug Walker 2% 

Commissioner James Gordon Total Votes: 34

  1. 1. Gary Oldman 35% 
  2. 2. David Strathairn 8% 
  3. 3. Donald Sutherland 8% 
  4. 4. Robert de Niro 8% 
  5. 5. Burt Reynolds 5% 
  6. 6. Harrison Ford 5% 
  7. 7. Harvey Keitel 5% 
  8. 8. Sam Elliott 5% 
  9. 9. Charles Durning 2% 
  10. 10. Michael Douglas 2% 
  11. 11. Bruce Dern 2% 
  12. 12. Brendan Gleeson 2% 
  13. 13. Pat Hingle 2% 

Robin/Carrie Kelly Total Votes: 31

  1. 1. Emma Watson 16% 
  2. 2. Hailee Steinfeld 12% 
  3. 3. Dakota Fanning 9% 
  4. 4. Chloe Grace Moretz 9% 
  5. 5. Danielle Panabaker 6% 
  6. 6. Blake Lively 6% 
  7. 7. Kristen Bell 3% 
  8. 8. Julianne Hough 3% 
  9. 9. Tom Cruise 3% 
  10. 10. Kay Panabaker 3% 
  11. 11. Anna Paquin 3% 
  12. 12. Saoirse Ronan 3% 
  13. 13. Ellen Page 3% 
  14. 14. Jennifer Lawrence 3% 
  15. 15. Elle Fanning 3% 
  16. 16. Joey King 3% 
  17. 17. McKenna Grace 3% 
  18. 18. Aryana Engineer 3% 

Harvey Dent Total Votes: 32

  1. 1. Tommy Lee Jones 37% 
  2. 2. Greg Kinnear 6% 
  3. 3. Al Pacino 6% 
  4. 4. Bryan Cranston 6% 
  5. 5. Billy Dee Williams 6% 
  6. 6. Robert de Niro 3% 
  7. 7. Chris Cooper 3% 
  8. 8. Aaron Eckhardt 3% 
  9. 9. Aaron Eckhart 3% 
  10. 10. Richard Gere 3% 
  11. 11. Kevin Spacey 3% 
  12. 12. Christopher Walken 3% 
  13. 13. Frank Welker 3% 
  14. 14. Tom Hanks 3% 
  15. 15. Christoph Waltz 3% 
  16. 16. Ray Liotta 3% 
  17. 17. Mark Strong 3% 

Alfred Pennyworth Total Votes: 34

  1. 1. Michael Caine 35% 
  2. 2. John Hurt 11% 
  3. 3. Michael Gough 8% 
  4. 4. Christopher Plummer 8% 
  5. 5. Michael Gambon 5% 
  6. 6. Roger Moore 5% 
  7. 7. John Cleese 2% 
  8. 8. John Paxton 2% 
  9. 9. Dick van Dyke 2% 
  10. 10. Christopher Lee 2% 
  11. 11. Frank Langella 2% 
  12. 12. Robert Pugh 2% 
  13. 13. Hector Elizondo 2% 
  14. 14. Julian Glover 2% 

Mutant Leader Total Votes: 27

  1. 1. Derek Mears 29% 
  2. 2. Michael Clarke Duncan 14% 
  3. 3. Tyler Mane 14% 
  4. 4. Mickey Rourke 11% 
  5. 5. Nathan Jones 3% 
  6. 6. Sylvester Stallone 3% 
  7. 7. Robert Maillet 3% 
  8. 8. Conan Stevens 3% 
  9. 9. Andrew Bryniarski 3% 
  10. 10. Javier Bardem 3% 
  11. 11. Kimbo Slice 3% 
  12. 12. Dwayne Johnson 3% 

Green Arrow Total Votes: 28

  1. 1. Daniel Craig 21% 
  2. 2. Jeff Bridges 21% 
  3. 3. Cary Elwes 14% 
  4. 4. Pierce Brosnan 14% 
  5. 5. Sean Connery 3% 
  6. 6. Denis Leary 3% 
  7. 7. Paul Bettany 3% 
  8. 8. Jeff Fahey 3% 
  9. 9. John Slattery 3% 
  10. 10. Christopher McDonald 3% 
  11. 11. Matthew McConaughey 3% 
  12. 12. Hugh Jackman 3% 

Selina Kyle Total Votes: 31

  1. 1. Michelle Pfeiffer 41% 
  2. 2. Sean Young 9% 
  3. 3. Shawnee Smith 9% 
  4. 4. Madeleine Stowe 6% 
  5. 5. Helena Bonham Carter 6% 
  6. 6. Lynda Carter 3% 
  7. 7. Michelle Phieffer 3% 
  8. 8. Carla Gugino 3% 
  9. 9. Meryl Streep 3% 
  10. 10. Bernadette Peters 3% 
  11. 11. Catherine O'hara 3% 
  12. 12. Angelina Jolie 3% 
  13. 13. Linda Fiorentino 3% 

Site News

After nearly two decades, Imagine Casting will be shutting down on 10/31/2022.

Unfortunately we are no longer able to dedicate the time and resources needed to keep the site running. The site will soon enter a "read-only" mode and no new casts or votes will be accepted. And then the site will be taken offline on October 31st.

Comments

  • Dan: It's obvious to me that the next BATMAN film is going to be called THE DARK KNIGHT RETURNS

view all comments

x

Lost password?

email: