Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting
clear  
clear  

Sherlock Holmes by Arthur Conan Doyle

a multi-part movie series chronicling the many adventures of Sherlock Holmes and his personal war against his mortal enemy Professor Moriarty.

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 16

  1. 1. Christopher Nolan 50% 
  2. 2. Gore Verbinski 12% 
  3. 3. Zack Snyder 12% 
  4. 4. Tim Burton 6% 
  5. 5. Guy Ritchie 6% 
  6. 6. Fred Zinneman 6% 
  7. 7. David Yates 6% 

Cast Results

Sherlock Holmes Total Votes: 21

  1. 1. Christian Bale 23% 
  2. 2. Ralph Fiennes 9% 
  3. 3. Robert Downey Jr. 9% 
  4. 4. Johnny Depp 9% 
  5. 5. Jason Isaacs 4% 
  6. 6. Peter O'toole 4% 
  7. 7. Jeremy Brett 4% 
  8. 8. David Mitchell 4% 
  9. 9. Adrien Brody 4% 
  10. 10. David Tennant 4% 
  11. 11. James Ash 4% 
  12. 12. Aidan Gillen 4% 
  13. 13. Ioan Gruffudd 4% 
  14. 14. Colin Farrell 4% 

Doctor John Watson Total Votes: 20

  1. 1. Johnny Depp 25% 
  2. 2. Hugo Weaving 15% 
  3. 3. Jude Law 15% 
  4. 4. Edward Hardwicke 10% 
  5. 5. Tom Hardy 10% 
  6. 6. Peter Sellers 5% 
  7. 7. Damian Lewis 5% 
  8. 8. Matt Smith 5% 
  9. 9. Dominic Cooper 5% 
  10. 10. Karl Urban 5% 

Irene Adler Total Votes: 19

  1. 1. Scarlett Johansson 36% 
  2. 2. Cate Blanchett 21% 
  3. 3. Emily Blunt 10% 
  4. 4. Julie Christie 5% 
  5. 5. Rachel McAdams 5% 
  6. 6. Gayle Hunnicutt 5% 
  7. 7. Gillian Anderson 5% 
  8. 8. Gemma Arterton 5% 
  9. 9. Keira Knightley 5% 

Professor James Moriarty Total Votes: 20

  1. 1. Alan Rickman 40% 
  2. 2. Christoph Waltz 10% 
  3. 3. Daniel Day-Lewis 10% 
  4. 4. Christopher Lee 5% 
  5. 5. Alec Guinness 5% 
  6. 6. Jared Harris 5% 
  7. 7. Eric Porter 5% 
  8. 8. Hugh Laurie 5% 
  9. 9. Andrew Scott 5% 
  10. 10. Christian Bale 5% 
  11. 11. Anthony Hopkins 5% 

Inspector Lestrade Total Votes: 18

  1. 1. Christoph Waltz 38% 
  2. 2. Liam Neeson 16% 
  3. 3. Eddie Marsan 11% 
  4. 4. Gary Oldman 11% 
  5. 5. Lee Evans 5% 
  6. 6. John Gielgud 5% 
  7. 7. Colin Jeavons 5% 
  8. 8. Jean Remo 5% 

Mycroft Holmes Total Votes: 17

  1. 1. Liam Neeson 47% 
  2. 2. Stephen Fry 23% 
  3. 3. Tim Roth 5% 
  4. 4. Jim Broadbent 5% 
  5. 5. Peter Ustinov 5% 
  6. 6. Charles Gray 5% 
  7. 7. Guy Pearce 5% 

Tobias Gregson Total Votes: 10

  1. 1. Robbie Coltrane 80% 
  2. 2. Oliver Maguire 10% 
  3. 3. Callum Keith Rennie 10% 

Mrs. Hudson Total Votes: 13

  1. 1. Geraldine James 30% 
  2. 2. Angela Lansbury 15% 
  3. 3. Judi Dench 15% 
  4. 4. Jenny Seagrove 7% 
  5. 5. Phyllida Law 7% 
  6. 6. Rosalie Williams 7% 
  7. 7. Joan Plowright 7% 
  8. 8. Diana Rigg 7% 

Sebastian Moran Total Votes: 12

  1. 1. Alfred Molina 41% 
  2. 2. John Hurt 25% 
  3. 3. Robert Shaw 8% 
  4. 4. Patrick Allen 8% 
  5. 5. Paul Anderson 8% 
  6. 6. David Bowie 8% 

Mary Morstan Total Votes: 13

  1. 1. Kelly Reilly 23% 
  2. 2. Gwenyth Paltrow 15% 
  3. 3. Sienna Miller 15% 
  4. 4. Gwyneth Paltrow 15% 
  5. 5. Rose Leslie 15% 
  6. 6. Vanessa Redgeave 7% 
  7. 7. Jenny Seagrove 7% 

Inspector Bradstreet Total Votes: 10

  1. 1. John Cleese 60% 
  2. 2. Michael Caine 20% 
  3. 3. Denis Lill 10% 
  4. 4. Ralph Fiennes 10% 

Stanley Hopkins Total Votes: 9

  1. 1. Sam Worthington 33% 
  2. 2. Tom Hardy 22% 
  3. 3. John Cleese 22% 
  4. 4. Nigel Planer 11% 
  5. 5. Elyes Gabel 11% 

Comments

  • freddie: john cleese as holmes colin firth as watson
  • JMan: I really liked the new one with Robert Downey Jr. and Jude Law. But an alternate cast that could have been cool I think would ...

view all comments

Popular Titles

On Moonlight Bay

A Remake of the 1951 film starring Doris Day.

In The Bedroom (1991)

What if it was made 10 years earlier?

In The Bedroom (1981)

What if it was made in the 80s?

Fant4stic (2025)

Fant4stic made 10 years later

Captain America Civil War (2026)

Captain America Civil War made 10 years later

x

Lost password?

email: