Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting
clear  
clear  

The Hobbit by J.R.R. Tolkien

This prequel will likely happen soon considering LOTR's tremendous success and PJ's desire to direct it. Should Ian Holm reprise his role with airbrushed wrinkles or should a younger actor be selected? Who should voice Smaug? You will decide. And the last light of the setting sun will shine upon the keyhole...

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 54

  1. 1. Peter Jackson 70% 
  2. 2. Guillermo Del Toro 16% 
  3. 3. Terry Gilliam 5% 
  4. 4. Ron Howard 1% 
  5. 5. Mel Gibson 1% 
  6. 6. Peter Weir 1% 
  7. 7. Alfonso Cuaron 1% 

Cast Results

Bilbo Baggins Total Votes: 65

  1. 1. Martin Freeman 30% 
  2. 2. Ian Holm 29% 
  3. 3. Warwick Davis 10% 
  4. 4. Simon Pegg 6% 
  5. 5. James McAvoy 6% 
  6. 6. Colin Firth 3% 
  7. 7. Paul Giamatti 1% 
  8. 8. Philip Seymour Hoffman 1% 
  9. 9. Ian Hart 1% 
  10. 10. Colm Meaney 1% 
  11. 11. Marin Freeman 1% 
  12. 12. Andrew Levy 1% 
  13. 13. J.r. Killigrew 1% 
  14. 14. Tobey Maguire 1% 
  15. 15. Matthew Goode 1% 

Galdalf the Grey Total Votes: 61

  1. 1. Ian McKellen 91% 
  2. 2. Sean Connery 3% 
  3. 3. Tom Baker 1% 
  4. 4. Bill Nighy 1% 
  5. 5. John Hurt 1% 

Thorin Oakenshield Total Votes: 44

  1. 1. Anthony Hopkins 27% 
  2. 2. Brian Cox 27% 
  3. 3. Robbie Coltrane 9% 
  4. 4. Brendan Gleeson 6% 
  5. 5. Sean Connery 4% 
  6. 6. Bob Hoskins 4% 
  7. 7. Richard Armitage 4% 
  8. 8. Ralf Mueller 2% 
  9. 9. Michael Caine 2% 
  10. 10. John Rhys-Davies 2% 
  11. 11. Brian Blessed 2% 
  12. 12. Ray Winstone 2% 
  13. 13. Eddie Izzard 2% 
  14. 14. Peter Dinklage 2% 

Elrond Total Votes: 59

  1. 1. Hugo Weaving 93% 
  2. 2. David Bowie 3% 
  3. 3. Kenneth Branagh 1% 
  4. 4. Liam Neeson 1% 

Gollum Total Votes: 62

  1. 1. Andy Serkis 90% 
  2. 2. Thurl Ravenscroft 1% 
  3. 3. Eric Burton 1% 
  4. 4. Adam Serkis 1% 
  5. 5. Bill Schulz 1% 
  6. 6. Pat Fraley 1% 
  7. 7. Andy Serkis (voice) 1% 

King of the Wood-elves Total Votes: 43

  1. 1. Jason Isaacs 30% 
  2. 2. Guy Pearce 11% 
  3. 3. Willem Dafoe 11% 
  4. 4. David Bowie 9% 
  5. 5. Gerard Butler 4% 
  6. 6. Bill Nighy 4% 
  7. 7. Sam Neill 4% 
  8. 8. Liam Neeson 2% 
  9. 9. Val Kilmer 2% 
  10. 10. Cripin Glover 2% 
  11. 11. Timothy Dalton 2% 
  12. 12. Robson Green 2% 
  13. 13. Josh Holloway 2% 
  14. 14. Doug Jones 2% 
  15. 15. Jonny Depp 2% 
  16. 16. David Tennant 2% 
  17. 17. Lee Pace 2% 

Legolas (in a cameo) Total Votes: 52

  1. 1. Orlando Bloom 88% 
  2. 2. No One 3% 
  3. 3. Natalie Portman 1% 
  4. 4. Joaquin Phoenix 1% 
  5. 5. Orlano Bloom 1% 
  6. 6. Keith Scott 1% 

Smaug (voice) Total Votes: 45

  1. 1. Jeremy Irons 17% 
  2. 2. James Earl Jones 15% 
  3. 3. Tim Curry 8% 
  4. 4. Ron Perlman 8% 
  5. 5. Christopher Lee 6% 
  6. 6. Samuel L. Jackson 4% 
  7. 7. John Rhys-Davies 4% 
  8. 8. Timothy Dalton 4% 
  9. 9. Brad Dourif 2% 
  10. 10. Jim Cummings 2% 
  11. 11. Phillipe Noiret 2% 
  12. 12. Jack Palance 2% 
  13. 13. Sean Connery 2% 
  14. 14. Jason Isaacs 2% 
  15. 15. Rachel Youngberg 2% 
  16. 16. Michael Wincott 2% 
  17. 17. Leonard Nimoy 2% 
  18. 18. Christopher Lloyd 2% 
  19. 19. Geoffrey Rush (voice) 2% 
  20. 20. Bill Nighy 2% 
  21. 21. Benedict Cumberbatch 2% 

Gloin Total Votes: 29

  1. 1. John Rhys-Davies 41% 
  2. 2. Robbie Coltrane 27% 
  3. 3. Brendan Gleeson 13% 
  4. 4. Bob Hoskins 6% 
  5. 5. Joel Grey 3% 
  6. 6. Jeffrey Tambor 3% 
  7. 7. Alfred Molina 3% 

Dori Total Votes: 18

  1. 1. Mark Addy 55% 
  2. 2. Ray Winstone 27% 
  3. 3. Donald Sutherland 5% 
  4. 4. Andy Serkis 5% 
  5. 5. Mark Hadlow 5% 

Balin Total Votes: 26

  1. 1. Sean Connery 26% 
  2. 2. Robbie Coltrane 23% 
  3. 3. Brian Cox 15% 
  4. 4. Timothy Spall 11% 
  5. 5. Billy Connolly 7% 
  6. 6. Eric Idle 3% 
  7. 7. Tony Jay 3% 
  8. 8. Ray Winstone 3% 
  9. 9. Bill Bailey 3% 

Bombur Total Votes: 23

  1. 1. Alan Rickman 30% 
  2. 2. Oliver Platt 21% 
  3. 3. Robbie Coltrane 13% 
  4. 4. Ricky Tomlinson 8% 
  5. 5. Colm Meaney 8% 
  6. 6. Stephen Hunter 8% 
  7. 7. Ray Winstone 4% 
  8. 8. Timothy Spall 4% 

Dwalin Total Votes: 20

  1. 1. Richard Griffiths 40% 
  2. 2. Brian Blessed 10% 
  3. 3. Ricky Gervais 10% 
  4. 4. Graham McTavish 10% 
  5. 5. Michael Palin 5% 
  6. 6. Tom Baker 5% 
  7. 7. Jamie MacPhee 5% 
  8. 8. Brian Cox 5% 
  9. 9. Stellen Skarsgard 5% 
  10. 10. Matt Lucas 5% 

Kili Total Votes: 19

  1. 1. Bob Hoskins 52% 
  2. 2. Thomas Kretschmann 10% 
  3. 3. Mark Addy 10% 
  4. 4. Adrian Edminson 5% 
  5. 5. Timothy Spall 5% 
  6. 6. Thomas Krestchmann 5% 
  7. 7. Simon Pegg 5% 
  8. 8. Aidan Turner 5% 

Oin Total Votes: 17

  1. 1. Brendan Gleeson 47% 
  2. 2. Martin Short 17% 
  3. 3. Patrick Roach 11% 
  4. 4. Damian Lewis 5% 
  5. 5. Timothy Spall 5% 
  6. 6. Kai Owens 5% 
  7. 7. John Callen 5% 

Ori Total Votes: 16

  1. 1. Mark Williams 25% 
  2. 2. Geoffrey Rush 25% 
  3. 3. Ricky Gervais 12% 
  4. 4. Oliver Platt 12% 
  5. 5. Stuart Townsend 6% 
  6. 6. Richard Collins 6% 
  7. 7. Some Short/fat Guy 6% 
  8. 8. Adam Brown 6% 

Nori Total Votes: 16

  1. 1. Stephen Graham 37% 
  2. 2. Alan Rickman 12% 
  3. 3. Ben Chaplin 6% 
  4. 4. Charlie Higson 6% 
  5. 5. John Rhys-Davies 6% 
  6. 6. Wayne Knight 6% 
  7. 7. James Cosmo 6% 
  8. 8. Brendan Gleeson 6% 
  9. 9. Nick Frost 6% 
  10. 10. Some Short/fat Guy 6% 

Bifur Total Votes: 15

  1. 1. Ian McDiarmid 40% 
  2. 2. John Hillerman 13% 
  3. 3. Ricky Gervais 13% 
  4. 4. Matthew G. Taylor 6% 
  5. 5. Sam Neill 6% 
  6. 6. Richard Griffiths 6% 
  7. 7. Vinnie Jones 6% 
  8. 8. Some Short/fat Guy 6% 

Bofur Total Votes: 17

  1. 1. Tom Wilkinson 35% 
  2. 2. Dustin Hoffman 23% 
  3. 3. Michael Rapaport 11% 
  4. 4. David Weatherley 11% 
  5. 5. Nick Frost 5% 
  6. 6. Some Short/fat Guy 5% 
  7. 7. James Nesbitt 5% 

Fili Total Votes: 16

  1. 1. F. Murray Abraham 25% 
  2. 2. Simon Pegg 25% 
  3. 3. Oliver Platt 18% 
  4. 4. Colm Meaney 18% 
  5. 5. Nick Frost 6% 
  6. 6. Rob Kazinsky 6% 

Lord of the Eagles (voice) Total Votes: 27

  1. 1. John Hurt 44% 
  2. 2. David Ogden Stiers 14% 
  3. 3. Willem Dafoe 7% 
  4. 4. Christopher Lee 7% 
  5. 5. Alan Rickman 7% 
  6. 6. Mark Everitt 3% 
  7. 7. James Earl Jones 3% 
  8. 8. Jim Cummings 3% 
  9. 9. Julian Sands 3% 
  10. 10. Brian Blessed 3% 

William (Troll) Total Votes: 23

  1. 1. Jason Statham 30% 
  2. 2. Robbie Coltrane 13% 
  3. 3. Ian McNeice 13% 
  4. 4. Jeffrey Kurland 8% 
  5. 5. Steve Pemberton 4% 
  6. 6. Paul Whitehouse 4% 
  7. 7. Christopher Robin 4% 
  8. 8. Eric Idle 4% 
  9. 9. Bruce Spence 4% 
  10. 10. Tyler Mane 4% 
  11. 11. John Ratzenberger 4% 
  12. 12. Timothy Spall (voice) 4% 

Bert (Troll) Total Votes: 22

  1. 1. Jason Flemyng 40% 
  2. 2. Mark Addy 9% 
  3. 3. Paul Giamatti 9% 
  4. 4. Simon Day 9% 
  5. 5. Steven Randazzo 4% 
  6. 6. Mark Gatiss 4% 
  7. 7. Albert Finney 4% 
  8. 8. Michael Palin 4% 
  9. 9. Doug Jones 4% 
  10. 10. Derek Mears 4% 
  11. 11. Steve Speirs (voice) 4% 

Tom (Troll) Total Votes: 22

  1. 1. Vinnie Jones 45% 
  2. 2. John Goodman 9% 
  3. 3. Albert Finney 9% 
  4. 4. Jack Warden 4% 
  5. 5. Reece Shearsmith 4% 
  6. 6. Mark Williams 4% 
  7. 7. Richard Griffith 4% 
  8. 8. Terry Jones 4% 
  9. 9. Brian Steele 4% 
  10. 10. Andrew Bryniarski 4% 
  11. 11. Matt Lucas (voice) 4% 

Beorn Total Votes: 25

  1. 1. Russell Crowe 28% 
  2. 2. The Rock 12% 
  3. 3. Brian Blessed 8% 
  4. 4. Kevin Grevioux 8% 
  5. 5. Robert Downey Jr. 4% 
  6. 6. Robbie Coltrane 4% 
  7. 7. Predrag Bjelac 4% 
  8. 8. Liam Neeson 4% 
  9. 9. Christian Bale 4% 
  10. 10. Doug Jones 4% 
  11. 11. John DeSantis 4% 
  12. 12. Gerald Butler 4% 
  13. 13. Gerard Butler 4% 
  14. 14. Ron Perlman 4% 
  15. 15. Mikael Persbrandt 4% 

The Great Goblin Total Votes: 27

  1. 1. Rhys Ifans 25% 
  2. 2. Lawrence Makoare 14% 
  3. 3. James Cosmos 7% 
  4. 4. Frank Welker 7% 
  5. 5. Ice Cube 3% 
  6. 6. Jay Laga'aia 3% 
  7. 7. Sala Baker 3% 
  8. 8. Dj Qualls 3% 
  9. 9. Ted Levine 3% 
  10. 10. Lenny Henry 3% 
  11. 11. Rachel Youngberg 3% 
  12. 12. Jonathan Rhys Meyers 3% 
  13. 13. Doug Jones 3% 
  14. 14. Greg Gutfeld 3% 
  15. 15. Temuera Morrison 3% 
  16. 16. Barry Humphries 3% 

The Master of Esgaroth Total Votes: 17

  1. 1. Ralph Fiennes 29% 
  2. 2. Sam Neill 23% 
  3. 3. Damian Lewis 11% 
  4. 4. Alan Rickman 11% 
  5. 5. Rachel Youngberg 5% 
  6. 6. Temuera Morrison 5% 
  7. 7. Anthony Hopkins 5% 
  8. 8. David Thewlis 5% 

Bard Total Votes: 28

  1. 1. Joaquin Phoenix 21% 
  2. 2. Liam Neeson 7% 
  3. 3. Dean Cain 7% 
  4. 4. Eric Bana 7% 
  5. 5. Peter Weller 3% 
  6. 6. Matthew G. Taylor 3% 
  7. 7. Benjamin McKenzie 3% 
  8. 8. Martin Henderson 3% 
  9. 9. Nicole Kidman 3% 
  10. 10. Rachel Youngberg 3% 
  11. 11. Damian Lewis 3% 
  12. 12. Henry Cavill 3% 
  13. 13. Richard Armitage 3% 
  14. 14. Karl Urban 3% 
  15. 15. Christian Bale 3% 
  16. 16. Tobey Maguire 3% 
  17. 17. Tom Welling 3% 
  18. 18. Dougray Scott 3% 
  19. 19. Michael Fassbender 3% 
  20. 20. Luke Evans 3% 

Comments

  • agentsnipe: I think casting Ian Holm as a young Bilbo Baggins would be difficult to pull off for an entire moive but at the same time ...
  • Spoon: Why would Legolas make a cameo? And, are we really supposed to cast 12 dwarves or whatever? I mean, seriously. I looked around other sites ...
  • gorey: Read the FAQ to see how to edit your posts to avoid double posts.
  • IceElf: Yes The Elf King Thranduil was Legolas Father, and so why would Legolas not be there somewhere? He'd more than likely be at the Battle ...

view all comments

Popular Titles

Metroid (90's Movie)

What if Metroid was a Movie in the 1990's?

The Invaders (Nickelodeon Actors)

What if the cast of The Invaders were Nickelodeon actors?

Kirby (90's Animated Movie)

What if Kirby had an Animated Movie back in the 1990's?

The Peering Head

Based on Mr. Nightmare’s original Creepypasta “The Peering Head” A guy moves away from his ...

The British Bulldog

A biopic about the famed Prime Minister, Winston Churchill.

x

Lost password?

email: