Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting

SUPERMAN by Andrew Milito

Despite a longtime disinterest in the character, I've found myself really in love with Superman within the past five years or so. What I used to see as a boring, weakness-free hero suddenly became a beautiful figure of acceptance and honor and justice. Much of that came from Zack Snyder's Man of Steel, but that film soured just slightly for me as it settled in my mind, alongside a viewing of Richard Donner's 1978 classic which I much prefer.

So, nostalgic throwback aside, I thought about my ideal portrayal of the Man of Steel himself, which eventually kickstarted a whole DC cinematic universe idea (maybe I'll finish that someday…) But now, having experienced many different portrayals of the character, I'd like to revisit my original idea and both tweak and elaborate on how I'd approach the character in a perfect world.

The movie would, of course, begin with a “prologue” on the planet Krypton. Scientist Jor-El has uncovered evidence that, very soon, a disruption within the nearest sun will explode, wiping the race of Kryptonians from existence completely. He takes this message to the Council of Krypton, who refuse his evidence on their own terms. With the clock ticking, Jor-El and his wife Lara Lor-Van decide to send their newborn son, Kal-El, to a distant planet, sustaining the race as the last son of Krypton. He prepares an escape pod, outfitted with data containing an extent of the minds of Jor-El and Lara Lor-Van, and set its destination: a distant planet called Earth. The pod departs just as the planet is completely destroyed.

The rest of the movie would follow two very distinct periods of Kal-El's life on Earth, in which his pod crashes in rural Kansas and he is adopted by farm couple Jonathan and Martha Kent as their son Clark, in somewhat non-linear fashion: age 15, and approximately 10 years later.

The Young Clark timeline follows a pre-Superman, coming-of-age story. Clark's true identity has been hidden from him by Jonathan and Martha, but only to the best of their ability: Clark begins to discover, and use, his powers at his own will, and often for his own amusement. He discovers his ability to fly, his enhanced strength and speed, and, of course, the emotions that come with such discoveries: excitement, but also fear. In school, Clark's few outbursts of his powers have cemented him as an outcast; however, he harbors feelings for classmate Lana Lang, and, against better judgment, uses his powers in an attempt to win her over. The timeline would ultimately culminate with Jonathan and Martha sitting Clark down and telling him his true origins. Both the Kents and the El family, whom Clark discovers in his stowed away pod, tell of their desires (and in the case of the Kents, their change of heart) for Clark/Kal-El to put his powers to use for the good of humankind.

The Adult Clark timeline follows him in the days of what the world has deemed “Superman,” a character that's still in his infancy and has not set a consistent positive or negative view from the world. Clark, now working in the city of Metropolis as a reporter at the Daily Planet newspaper, balances his ordinary life with that of a benevolent superhero, and faces struggles in doing so. As Clark, he romances journalist Lois Lane, befriends young photographer Jimmy Olsen, is slowly introduced to Metropolis' famous philanthropist millionaire Alexander “Lex” Luthor, and helps tend to the farm of aging Jonathan and Martha back in Smallville. As Superman, he upholds a sense of justice within the city, and slowly sets the foundation for a troubled relationship with Luthor. This arc would conclude with Clark feeling at home in his new civilian life, and with Superman slowly becoming a positive aspect of Metropolis in the eyes of most everyone… except Luthor.

Unchanged from my original idea, I like to think this would be a very unconventional take on Superman, and one that would never happen realistically (at least onscreen). There would be no traditional villain (only the seeds of one that could be used for future movies), no huge action set pieces outside of Superman saving citizens. Just a quaint look at the character from two defining points in his life and the varying relationships in each period. Still very much inspired by Max Landis', one of my favorite writers, Superman: American Alien, and his general view of the character.


Kal-El/Clark Kent
Jonathan Kent (same actor across both timelines)
Martha Kent (same actor across both timelines)
Lana Lang
Pete Ross - one of Clark's sole friends (he and Lana would briefly cameo in the Adult Clark timeline)

Kal-El/Clark Kent/Superman
Lois Lane
Jimmy Olsen
Perry White - editor-in-chief of the Daily Planet

Lara Lor-Van

Rated PG-13 for sequences of action, and some language.

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Jeff Nichols 100% 

Cast Results

Kal-El/Clark Kent/Superman (age 25) Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Alex Russell 33% 
  2. 2. Robbie Amell 33% 
  3. 3. Armie Hammer 33% 

Kal-El/Clark Kent (age 15) Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Lucas Jade Zumann 50% 
  2. 2. Jaeden Lieberher 50% 

Jonathan Kent Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Tom Hanks 33% 
  2. 2. Dennis Quaid 33% 
  3. 3. Bruce Greenwood 33% 

Martha Kent Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Julianne Moore 100% 

Lois Lane Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Mary Elizabeth Winstead 33% 
  2. 2. Antonia Thomas 33% 
  3. 3. Rachel McAdams 33% 

Alexander "Lex" Luthor Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Joaquin Phoenix 66% 
  2. 2. Damian Lewis 33% 

Jimmy Olsen Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Liam James 66% 
  2. 2. Will Poulter 33% 

Perry White Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Bruce Campbell 33% 
  2. 2. Keith David 33% 
  3. 3. Jeff Bridges 33% 

Lana Lang Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. MacKenzie Foy 100% 

Pete Ross Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Jeremy Ray Taylor 50% 
  2. 2. Gaten Matarazzo 50% 

Jor-El Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Sean Bean 33% 
  2. 2. Michael Trucco 33% 
  3. 3. Ralph Fiennes 33% 

Lara Lor-Van Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Jennifer Connelly 33% 
  2. 2. Julia Ormond 33% 
  3. 3. Cate Blanchett 33% 


  • vin13ish: What do you think of Wonder Woman movie? They called it “Best DCEU movie” and got 92 FRESH on Rotten Tomatoes! I hasn't see it …
  • PointMan528491:

    vin13ish wrote:
    What do you think of Wonder Woman movie? They called it “Best DCEU movie” and got 92 FRESH on Rotten Tomatoes! I hasn't see it …

  • NerdBoy359: Awesome title i loved Max Landis's Superman American Alien Run as well also I created a new title for my brand new Nickeloden Cinematic Universe …
  • WolfLogan: Would like to know your thoughts on my Batman reboot idea []

view all comments

Popular Titles

My Crazy Rich Pregnant Girlfriend

Plot: Jason Young, a struggling musician composer who quit composed music theme for TV show …

Monster House (Live-Action)

What if 2006 Monster House was Made a Live-Action


Plot: Two bank robbers decided to become one of the infamous robbers in america history. …

Scott Pilgrim vs. The World: The Animated Series

From the Writers of DC Super Hero Girls, My Little Pony: Friendship is Magic and …

Halloween (1969)

What if Halloween came out in the 1960's?


Lost password?