Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting


This is a more faithful adaptation of the original book.

In 1890s Paris, the Palais Garnier is believed to be haunted by an entity known as “The Phantom” or “The Opera Ghost”. One day, the stage hand, Joseph Bouquet, is found hanged, presumably by The Phantom, after boasting about him to the corps de ballet. At the same time, Christine Daaé, a young Swedish soprano, has been tutored by what she believes to be “the Angel of Music,” sent by her deceased father. On the night of the old manager's retirement, she understudies at the gala performance for the Opera's leading soprano, Carlotta, and her performance is an astonishing success. The Vicomte, Raoul de Chagny, who was present at the performance, recognises her as his childhood playmate, and recalls his love for her. He attempts to visit her backstage, when he hears a man speaking to her from inside her dressing room. He investigates the room once Christine leaves, only to find that there's no one else in the room. At Perros-Guirec, Christine meets with Raoul, who confronts her about the voice he heard in her room. Christine tells him about The Angel that has been tutoring her, but he is sceptical and suggests that she might be the victim of a prank. Hurt and angry, she storms off. Christine visits her father's grave one night, where a mysterious figure appears and plays the violin for her. Raoul attempts to confront it but is attacked and knocked out in the process. Back at the Palais Garnier, the managers receive a letter from the Opera Ghost, demanding that they allow Christine to perform in the lead role of Marguerite in Faust, and that box 5 be left empty for his use, lest they perform in a house with a curse on it. The managers ignore his demands, resulting in disastrous consequences: Carlotta ends up croaking like a toad, and the chandelier suddenly drops into the audience, killing the new concierge. The Phantom, having abducted Christine from her dressing room, reveals himself as Erik, and that he has been the one tutoring her. He intends on keeping her in his lair with him for a few days, but she causes Erik to change his plans when she unmasks him and, to the horror of both, beholds his noseless, lipless, sunken-eyed face which resembles a skull dried up by the centuries, covered in yellowed dead flesh. Fearing that she will leave him, he decides to keep her with him forever, but when Christine requests release after two weeks, he agrees on condition that she wear his ring and be faithful to him. On the roof of the opera house, Christine tells Raoul about her abduction and makes Raoul promise to take her away to a place where Erik can never find her, even if she resists. Raoul tells Christine he shall act on his promise the next day, to which she agrees. However, Christine sympathises with Erik and decides to sing for him one last time as a means of saying good-bye. Unbeknownst to them, Erik has been watching them and overheard their whole conversation. The following night, the enraged and jealous Erik abducts Christine during a production of Faust and tries to force her to marry him. Raoul, along with an old acquaintance of Erik's, known as The Persian, attempt to rescue her but are trapped by Erik, who states that unless Christine agrees to marry him, he will kill them and everyone in the Opera House by using explosives. To save them and the people above in the Opera, Christine agrees to marry Erik. Erik initially tries to drown Raoul and the Persian, using the water which would have been used to douse the explosives. But Christine begs and offers to be his “living bride”, promising him not to kill herself after becoming his bride, as she had both contemplated and attempted earlier in the novel. Erik eventually releases Raoul and the Persian from his torture chamber. When Erik is alone with Christine, he lifts his mask to kiss her on her forehead, and is given a kiss back. Erik reveals that he has never received a kiss (not even from his own mother) nor has been allowed to give one and is overcome with emotion. He and Christine then cry together and their tears “mingle”. Erik later expresses that he has never felt so close to another human being. He allows the Persian and Raoul to escape, though not before making Christine promise that she will visit him on his death day, and return the gold ring he gave her. He also makes the Persian promise that afterwards he will go to the newspaper and report his death, as he will die soon and will die “of love”. Indeed, some time later Christine returns to Erik's lair, buries him somewhere he'll never be found (by Erik's request) and returns the gold ring. Afterwards, a local newspaper runs the simple note: “Erik is dead”.


Erik - The “Phantom of the Opera”, also referred to as the “Angel of Music” and the “Opera-Ghost.” He tutors and eventually becomes obsessed with Christine Daaé.

Christine Daaé - A young Swedish soprano at the Paris Opera House with whom “The Phantom” falls in love.

Vicomte Raoul de Chagny - Christine's childhood friend and love interest.

The Persian - A mysterious man from Erik's past.

Comte Phillipe de Chagny - Raoul's older brother.

Armand Moncharmin and Firmin Richard - The new managers of the opera house.

Madame Giry - Little Meg's mother, the box keeper.

Meg Giry - Often referred to as “Little Meg”, Madame Giry's only daughter, a ballet girl. Later becomes Madame la Baronne de Castelot-Barbezac.

Debienne and Poligny - The previous managers of the opera house.

Joseph Buquet - The chief scene-shifter.

Carlotta - A spoiled prima donna; the lead soprano of the Paris Opera House.

Madame Valérius - Christine's elderly guardian.

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Brett Ratner 100% 

Cast Results

Erik/"The Phantom" Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Henry Cavill 50% 
  2. 2. Jim Cavizel 50% 

Christine Daaé Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Ruth Wilson (II) 100% 

Vicomte Raoul de Chagny Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Dan Stevens 100% 

The Persian Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Christopher Plummer 100% 

Comte Phillipe de Chagny Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes

Armand Moncharmin Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes

Firmin Richard Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Colin Farrell 100% 

Madame Giry Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Cate Blanchett 100% 

"Little" Meg Giry Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Keira Knightley 100% 

Debienne Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes

Poligny Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes

Joseph Buquet Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Alfed Molina 100% 

Carlotta Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Mia Sara 100% 

Madame Valérius Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Meryl Steep 100% 


  • NerdBoy359: Hey Rhyder i noticed that you didn't do artwork for my power crew entry Inner Demons i would be honored if you would do artwork …
  • Rhyder_Hawkman27:

    NerdBoy359 wrote:
    Hey Rhyder i noticed that you didn't do artwork for my power crew entry Inner Demons i would be honored if you would do artwork …

  • NerdBoy359:

    Rhyder_Hawkman27 wrote:

    NerdBoy359 wrote:
    Hey Rhyder i noticed that you didn't do artwork for my power crew entry Inner Demons i would be honored if you would do artwork …

view all comments

Popular Titles

Paul Thomas Anderson’s Crazy, Stupid Love

Crazy, Stupid Love directed by Paul Thomas Anderson


Since it’s been announced that the DCEU is headed for a reboot, I now have …

Denis Villeneuve's Crazy, Stupid, Love

What if Denis Villeneuve directed Crazy, Stupid, Love?

Wes Anderson's Crazy, Stupid, Love

What if Wes Anderson directed Crazy, Stupid, Love?


(My speculation for a sequel to The Batman, taking inspiration from the court of owls …


Lost password?