Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting

Super Mario Bros. (1992 live-action movie, actually faithful to the game) by ?

Did you know the 1993 live-action “Super Mario Bros.” movie could've been a LOT different? When it was first green-lighted in 1991, the first draft of the script envisioned a COMPLETELY different film, one that was actually faithful to the games. It would've involved Mario and Luigi (played by Danny DeVito and Steve Buscemi) as they attempt to rescue Princess Hildy (the princess was still called “Toadstool” in the US back then, so the producers wanted a better name) from the evil King Koopa (played by Arnold Schwarzenegger in very, VERY heavy makeup and costuming) in a wacky world reminiscent of The Wizard of Oz and Alice in Wonderland. This script laid the groundwork for how the characters were used by later writers: Mario is the reluctant hero, while Luigi is the dreamer who gets the girl. Both must overcome deep-stemmed differences to become “brothers” for the first time.

The script, written by Tom S. Parker and Jim Jennewein (who would later write the “Richie Rich” movie and the “Flinstones” movie) can be found online here:

Sadly, this project fell apart when DeVito dropped out due to scheduling conflicts, Schwarzenegger declined to sign on, and director Greg Beeman (who would later produce and direct “Smallville”) quit due to creative differences with the studio. When the new directors, Rocky Morton and Annabel Jankel, came onto the project, they decided to scrap this script and write a new, sci-fi-oriented one, replace Bruno Kirby (who had briefly replaced DeVito) first with Tom Hanks and later Bob Hoskins, and replace Buscemi with John Leguizamo. The result? The film we see today.

But what if things went in a different direction? What if this project actually took off, produced without significant delays, and released in the summer of 1992 instead of the spring of 1993?

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Greg Beeman 33% 
  2. 2. Tim Burton 33% 
  3. 3. Rob Reiner 33% 

Cast Results

Mario Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Bob Hoskins 66% 
  2. 2. Danny DeVito 33% 

Luigi Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Steve Buscemi 33% 
  2. 2. Jon Polito 33% 
  3. 3. Tom Hanks 33% 

Princess Peach (called "Princess Hildy" in the movie) Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Julia Roberts 100% 

Toad Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Warwick Davis 100% 

Bowser (called "King Koopa" in the movie) Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Arnold Schwarzenegger (in Heavy Makeup And Costuming) 66% 
  2. 2. Dennis Hopper 33% 

Woltan the Wizard (SPOILER: He's actually the King of the Mushroom Kingdom) Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Max Von Sydow 100% 

Yoshi (called "Junior" in the movie) Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Frank Welker (voice) 100% 

Beedleman (this movie's equivalent of Kamek, who hadn't made his debut in the games yet) Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Mark Hamill 100% 

Mugger (a giant, muscular Koopa Troopa who's a secondary antagonist) Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Andre The Giant 100% 


No one has commented on this title.

Click below to be the first.

add a comment

Popular Titles

Ballad for the Brokenhearted

An original jukebox musical that follows the lives and daily struggles of two lost young …

Anna and the King

The story of the romance between the King of Siam and widowed British elementary teacher, …

Bleach The Movie: Hell Verse (Live-Action)

What if Bleach: The Movie Hell Verse was Made a Live Action


What if the Netflix Original “The Babysitter” was made as a well-known Hollywood movie? The …


A young Norwegian boy in 1850s England goes to work as a cabin boy and …


Lost password?