Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting

THEY (A VILLAGE REMAKE) by John Silver and M. Night Shyamalan

Starting off 2017 with my reinterpretation of M. Night Shyamalan's “The Village”. I was surprised at how different the movie turned out to be where the film was marketed as a horror thriller but turned into a romantic suspense, and I thought I'd make the film more supernatural and suspenseful while eliminating the romance elements and add a modern twist to my interpretation, borrowing some elements from the likes of The Witch, the new Blair Witch, and It Follows.

In a desolate small town in Pennsylvania, 1867, a small civilization lives far away from the rest of society after a series of mysterious events involved citizens living in the village disappeared, forcing the head of the town to lay down strict rules - no one leaves the village, no one mentions the incidents involved in or out of the village, and no one speaks nor thinks about the outside of the village. Ivy Walker and Lucius Hunt make the fatal mistake of leaving the woods after their request to get any medicine from the woods, ending up lost in the middle of the area and being pursued by unknown entities.

Lucius disappears and Ivy finds her way back to the Village after suffering a blackout and regaining some of her eyesight, only to be met with disdain and fear with villagers accusing Ivy of being a “witch” and returning with a curse to the town. Noah Percy, a young boy with a development disability acts strange when he starts painting blood red witchcraft symbols and speaks his sentences in reverse. Kitty (Ivy's sister) acts erratically, often dozing off into nightmarish and unquestionable scenarios. Some of the citizens witness animals dying under bewildering circumstances and a mutant arm appears within Alice Hunt's backyard.

However, Edward Walker (the head of town) seems to know a lot more about the outside of the woods than the rest of the small society, endangering himself and his daughter but Ivy soon starts to have visions of what lies outside the woods and the town immediately turns against both Edward and Ivy as they fear witchcraft entering the area and the creatures invade the territory, putting the village through a series of psychological manipulation and supernatural events.

MPAA: Rated R for horror violence, terror, and brief graphic nudity.
NOTE: See the comments for my twist idea and conclusion.

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 4

  1. 1. Fede Alvarez 75% 
  2. 2. David Robert Mitchell 25% 

Cast Results

Ivy Elizabeth Walker Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Emma Stone 100% 

Noah Percy Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Levi Miller 100% 

Edward Walker Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Gary Oldman 100% 

Alice Hunt Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Tilda Swinton 100% 

Lucius Hunt Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Jesse Plemons 100% 

August Nicholson Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Bruce McGill 100% 

Kitty Walker Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Karen Gillan 100% 

Mrs. Clack Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Cate Blanchett 100% 


  • MovieCriticGamer: TWIST: After the creatures invade the Village, it turns out Ivy entered another dimension while she searched for medication with Lucius and has regained her …
  • vin13ish: I am glad that you didn't add that twist where The Village was nothing but a government project! That and trees as a villain from …
  • MovieCriticGamer: Well, you can't always depend on the sci-fi government experiment cliche. I really thought hard and long on the twist, so I thought of The …
  • PointMan528491: Interesting interpretation! I like The Village (for the most part) and the way it was sort of focused on the romantic angle over the horror …

view all comments

Popular Titles

Planet Hulk (Live-Action)

The Incredible Hulk, ejected from Earth in a spaceship, crash-lands on a planet ruled by …


Ghost if it came out today

Black Swan (2020)

Black Swan if it came out today

Requiem for a Dream (2020)

Requiem for a Dream if it came out today

The Big Bang Theory (2017-29)

What if The Big Bang Theory aired 10 years ago?


Lost password?