Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting

Butter Wouldn't Melt by J.D Taylor

Mary Jo(22) and Lucy Anne(19) from Garlton County, Texas, are sick of their ultra-strict religious upbringing, overseen by their parents, Dorrell and Courtney Sue Horfield. One night, they steal their father's car and try to get as far away from their old life as possible. They head out of their hometown and out of Texas for good. In pursuit of a new life, they decide to see more of America. The sisters soon see the flipside of their new found freedom, and are exposed to the heartache and danger that comes with it. They find another obstacle is pursuing them, namely their folks, together with members of the church they pray in, who are vowing never to give up the chase until the young ladies are back home where they belong…

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Josh Boone 100% 

Cast Results

Mary Jo Horfield Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Bailey Noble 50% 
  2. 2. Shailene Woodley 50% 

Lucy Anne Horfield Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Jella Haase 50% 
  2. 2. Zoe Graham 50% 

Dorrell Horfield Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Steve Zahn 100% 

Courtney Sue Horfield Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Jennifer Ehle 100% 

Reverend Mitch Durton Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Edward Norton 100% 

Josh Ambrett Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes

Hannah Getz Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Elizabeth Gudenrath 100% 

Rob Handrell Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes


No one has commented on this title.

Click below to be the first.

add a comment

Popular Titles

Shape of Vengeance/Shape of Justice

A two-part radical reimagining of the Halloween franchise, inspired by recent events (involving police brutality …

Dawn of The Dead (2014)

10 years later

Planet Hulk (Live-Action)

The Incredible Hulk, ejected from Earth in a spaceship, crash-lands on a planet ruled by …


Ghost if it came out today

Black Swan (2020)

Black Swan if it came out today


Lost password?