Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting
clear  
clear  

American Superhero Story: Gotham by DC and Brad Falchuk and Ryan Murphy

What if the American Horror Story writers and cast did a show based on DC comics characters, beginning with Batman. It is done in the same style as AHS with things being dark, weird and creepy and the stories delving deep into the characters' minds and thoughts and feelings and explores difficult issues and humanity's capacity for evil.

Only one rule YOU CAN ONLY USE ACTORS WHO HAVE BEEN IN AHS!!!!

Also, there's a plot twist where the warden is the bad guy! Dun dun Duuuuuun!!!

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Ryan Murphy 100% 

Cast Results

Batman/Bruce Wayne Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Dylan McDermott 66% 
  2. 2. Matt Bomer 33% 

Commissioner James Gordon Total Votes: 4

  1. 1. Danny Huston 75% 
  2. 2. Ian McShane 25% 

Robin/Dick Grayson/Nightwing Total Votes: 4

  1. 1. Evan Peters 75% 
  2. 2. Finn Wittrock 25% 

Alfred Pennyworth Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Ian McShane 100% 

Robin/Jason Todd/Red Hood Total Votes: 4

  1. 1. Finn Wittrock 50% 
  2. 2. Neil Patrick Harris 25% 
  3. 3. Evan Peters 25% 

Batgirl/Barbara Gordon Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Kate Mara 50% 
  2. 2. Skyler Samuels 50% 

Robin/Tim Drake Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes

Joker/Red Hood/Jack Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Neil Patrick Harris 66% 
  2. 2. Matt Boner 33% 

Robin/Damien Wayne Total Votes: 0

  1. No Votes

Penguin/Oswald Cobblepot Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. John Carroll Lynch 33% 
  2. 2. Denis O'hare 33% 
  3. 3. Michael Chiklis 33% 

Poison Ivy/Pamela Isley Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Sarah Paulson 100% 

Bane Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Michael Chiklis 100% 

Catwoman/Selina Kyle Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Emma Roberts 50% 
  2. 2. Alexandra Breckenridge 50% 

Harvey Dent/Two Face Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Wes Bentley 66% 
  2. 2. Dylan McDermott 33% 

Harley Quinn Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. Lily Rabe 66% 
  2. 2. Alexandra Breckenridge 33% 

The Riddler/Edward Nigma Total Votes: 2

  1. 1. Zachary Quinto 50% 
  2. 2. Wes Bentley 50% 

Killer Croc Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Malcolm-Jamal Warner 100% 

Man-Bat Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Denis O'hare 100% 

Doctor Hugo Strange Total Votes: 3

  1. 1. James Cromwell 100% 

The Warden Total Votes: 1

  1. 1. Jessica Lange 100% 

Comments

No one has commented on this title.

Click below to be the first.

add a comment

Popular Titles

Marvel Daredevil: The Man Without Fear (The Animated Series)

Daredevil: The Animated Series is an American television show based off of the Marvel superhero …

The Dark Knight Returns

Bruce Wayne / Batman returns to Gotham City to take on the Riddler.

Mr Magoo

An eccentric billionaire defeats mug of thefts in his unusual rambling manner.

Ballad for the Brokenhearted

An original jukebox musical that follows the lives and daily struggles of two lost young …

Anna and the King

The story of the romance between the King of Siam and widowed British elementary teacher, …

x

Lost password?

email: