Imagine Casting
Imagine Casting

Imagine Casting will be shutdown permanently on October 31, 2022.

The site is now in read-only mode. No new casts, polls, votes, or comments can be added.

clear  
clear  

Captain America by Jack Kirby and Joe Simon

During World War II, a brave, patriotic American undergoes experiments to become a new supersoldier, “Captain America”. Racing to sabotage the plans of Nazi bad guy “The Red Skull”, Captain America then becomes frozen in suspended animation until present day.

posted: 07/03/2005 by Dan comments | results |

Director Results

Director Total Votes: 64

  1. 1. Steven Spielberg 25% 
  2. 2. Robert Zemeckis 7% 
  3. 3. Joe Johnston 7% 
  4. 4. Stan Lee 6% 
  5. 5. Kerry Conran 4% 
  6. 6. Bryan Singer 4% 
  7. 7. Ang Lee 4% 
  8. 8. Ridley Scott 4% 
  9. 9. Roland Emmerich 3% 
  10. 10. John Woo 3% 
  11. 11. Joss Whedon 3% 
  12. 12. Nick Cassavetes 3% 
  13. 13. Mel Gibson 1% 
  14. 14. Peter Jackson 1% 
  15. 15. Tim Burton 1% 
  16. 16. Edward Zwick 1% 
  17. 17. Martin Campbell 1% 
  18. 18. Wolfgang Petersen 1% 
  19. 19. Jared Hess 1% 
  20. 20. Sam Mendes 1% 
  21. 21. Peter Berg 1% 
  22. 22. Michael Mann 1% 
  23. 23. Jon Favreau 1% 
  24. 24. John Farveau 1% 
  25. 25. James Mangold 1% 
  26. 26. Jordan Vogt-Roberts 1% 

Cast Results

Captain America/Steve Rogers Total Votes: 74

  1. 1. Marc Blucas 12% 
  2. 2. Brad Pitt 10% 
  3. 3. Matthew McConaughey 8% 
  4. 4. Chris Evans 6% 
  5. 5. Josh Holloway 5% 
  6. 6. Mark Wahlberg 5% 
  7. 7. Leonardo Dicaprio 5% 
  8. 8. Josh Lucas 4% 
  9. 9. Cole Hauser 4% 
  10. 10. Chad Michael Murray 2% 
  11. 11. Aaron Eckhart 2% 
  12. 12. Chris Carmack 1% 
  13. 13. Russell Crowe 1% 
  14. 14. Captain America 1% 
  15. 15. Patrick Warburton 1% 
  16. 16. Kerry Conran 1% 
  17. 17. John Wesley Shipp 1% 
  18. 18. Ryan Reynolds 1% 
  19. 19. The Rock 1% 
  20. 20. Scott Steiner 1% 
  21. 21. Jason Lewis 1% 
  22. 22. Chuck Norris 1% 
  23. 23. Karl Urban 1% 
  24. 24. Neal McDonough 1% 
  25. 25. John Cena 1% 
  26. 26. Matt Damon 1% 
  27. 27. Paul Walker 1% 
  28. 28. Sam Worthington 1% 
  29. 29. Channing Tatum 1% 
  30. 30. John Barrowman 1% 
  31. 31. Garrett Hedlund 1% 
  32. 32. Mark Valley 1% 
  33. 33. James Roday 1% 
  34. 34. Paul Telfer 1% 
  35. 35. John Krasinski 1% 

The Red Skull/Johann Schmidt Total Votes: 63

  1. 1. Clive Owen 14% 
  2. 2. Alan Rickman 11% 
  3. 3. Hugo Weaving 9% 
  4. 4. Gary Oldman 6% 
  5. 5. John Malkovich 6% 
  6. 6. Frank Langella 4% 
  7. 7. Chris Walken 4% 
  8. 8. Ralph Fiennes 4% 
  9. 9. Thomas Kretschmann 3% 
  10. 10. Jurgen Prochnow 3% 
  11. 11. Karel Roden 3% 
  12. 12. Christoph Waltz 3% 
  13. 13. Joseph Fiennes 1% 
  14. 14. Stellen Skarsgard 1% 
  15. 15. John Lithgow 1% 
  16. 16. Sid Haig 1% 
  17. 17. Vinnie Jones 1% 
  18. 18. Gotz Otto 1% 
  19. 19. Steve Foley 1% 
  20. 20. Vin Diesel 1% 
  21. 21. Jeremy Irons 1% 
  22. 22. Rupert Everett 1% 
  23. 23. Michael Sheen 1% 
  24. 24. Jon Perlman 1% 
  25. 25. Daniel Craig 1% 
  26. 26. James Callis 1% 
  27. 27. Chris Eccleston 1% 
  28. 28. Jason Isaacs 1% 

James Buchanan "Bucky" Barnes Total Votes: 55

  1. 1. Elijah Wood 21% 
  2. 2. Shia Labeouf 12% 
  3. 3. Daniel Radcliffe 9% 
  4. 4. No One... Sidekicks Suck 9% 
  5. 5. Heath Ledger 7% 
  6. 6. Sebastian Stan 7% 
  7. 7. Giovanni Ribisi 3% 
  8. 8. Justin Berfield 3% 
  9. 9. Jason Lee 3% 
  10. 10. Frankie Muniz 3% 
  11. 11. Kieran Culkin 1% 
  12. 12. Christian Slater 1% 
  13. 13. Dane Cook 1% 
  14. 14. Andy Lawrence 1% 
  15. 15. Ethan Embry 1% 
  16. 16. Jack Black 1% 
  17. 17. Liam Aiken 1% 
  18. 18. Jared Padalecki 1% 
  19. 19. Josh Hutcherson 1% 
  20. 20. Logan Lerman 1% 

Dr. Emil Erskine (codename: Dr. Reinstein) Total Votes: 41

  1. 1. James Cromwell 34% 
  2. 2. John Hurt 17% 
  3. 3. William Hurt 14% 
  4. 4. Rade Sherbedgzia 9% 
  5. 5. James Woods 9% 
  6. 6. Stanley Tucci 4% 
  7. 7. Christopher Lloyd 2% 
  8. 8. Albert Einstein 2% 
  9. 9. John Rhys-Davies 2% 
  10. 10. Til Schwieger 2% 

President Franklin D. Roosevelt Total Votes: 46

  1. 1. Jon Voight 41% 
  2. 2. Kenneth Branagh 17% 
  3. 3. Tommy Lee Jones 13% 
  4. 4. Robert de Niro 10% 
  5. 5. Bernard Hill 4% 
  6. 6. Gene Hackman 4% 
  7. 7. Andy Romano 2% 
  8. 8. George Carlin 2% 
  9. 9. Tom Hanks 2% 
  10. 10. Jason Alexander 2% 

President Dwight Eisenhower Total Votes: 42

  1. 1. Robert Duvall 42% 
  2. 2. Tom Selleck 21% 
  3. 3. Patrick Stewart 11% 
  4. 4. Tom Hanks 7% 
  5. 5. Rod Steiger 4% 
  6. 6. Jack Nicholson 4% 
  7. 7. David Lyon 2% 
  8. 8. Peter Boyd 2% 
  9. 9. Charlie Sheen 2% 

Adolph Hitler Total Votes: 56

  1. 1. Robert Carlyle 28% 
  2. 2. Bruno Ganz 14% 
  3. 3. Robert de Niro 10% 
  4. 4. Gary Oldman 8% 
  5. 5. Noah Taylor 5% 
  6. 6. Ian McDiarmid 3% 
  7. 7. Jeff Goldblum 3% 
  8. 8. Robert Caryle 3% 
  9. 9. Nicky Katt 1% 
  10. 10. Dennis Hopper 1% 
  11. 11. Robert Downey Jr. 1% 
  12. 12. Bill Nye 1% 
  13. 13. Rob Lowe 1% 
  14. 14. Ciaran Hinds 1% 
  15. 15. Martin Wuttke 1% 
  16. 16. James Woods 1% 
  17. 17. Joseph Fiennes 1% 
  18. 18. David Bamber 1% 
  19. 19. Mitt Romney 1% 
  20. 20. Sascha Baron Cohen 1% 

Site News

After nearly two decades, Imagine Casting will be shutting down on 10/31/2022.

Unfortunately we are no longer able to dedicate the time and resources needed to keep the site running. The site will soon enter a "read-only" mode and no new casts or votes will be accepted. And then the site will be taken offline on October 31st.

Comments

  • tpound: Brad Pitt or Matt Damon as Captain America Steve Buscemi as Red Skull Steven Spielburg to direct
  • Dan: I found Captain America, listed as a upcoming future film which be released in 2007. I thought i'd submit and give the production manager, myself …
  • Jim: Giovanni Ribisi as Bucky? Seriously, folks.
  • spiderxand: At IGN Filmforce, Avi Arad has stated that the screenwriter will be David Self. Writer of both Sub-Mariner and Deathlock. He also wrote The Mummy …

view all comments

x

Lost password?

email: